This is a scholarly podcast about scholarly provocateurs. Gadflys, charlatans, and shitposters sometimes get tenure, believe it or not. This is a leftist podcast that takes a second look at their peer-reviewed work, and tries to see if there’s anything we might learn from arguing with them. We are hosted by: Victor Bruzzone, Gordon Katic, Matt McManus, and Ethan Xavier (AKA “Mouthy Infidel”).
…
continue reading
1
EP13: What if There’s No Meaning to Life? (On Benatar’s The Human Predicament)
1:23:15
1:23:15
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:23:15
This week we ask probably the most commonly uttered philosophical question: is there a meaning to life? To help us approach an answer, we read the first few chapters of philosopher David Benatar’s The Human Predicament. Benatar’s answer is as edgy as it gets. No, there’s no meaning to life, and no matter how much we try to soothe ourselves, this is…
…
continue reading
1
EP12: Is Making Friends with the Far-Right a Good Way to Research Them? (ft. Benjamin Teitelbaum)
1:08:48
1:08:48
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:08:48
In ethnography there has been a long-standing tradition to prioritize the interests of research participants through a scholar-informant solidarity. This week we ask, how far should this scholar-informant solidarity go in cases where the research participants are dangerous or otherwise unsavoury? In this episode, we interview Benjamin Teitelbaum ab…
…
continue reading
1
EP11: Is Post-Truth Actually Good? (On Fuller’s Post-Truth as Power Game)
1:11:16
1:11:16
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:11:16
We revisit a curious academic debate in science and technology studies, or STS. After 2016, some claimed that leftist humanities scholars played a role in creating the post-truth moment. And Steve Fuller argued that there’s nothing wrong with that. He likens post-truth to a kind of epistemic democratization that we should embrace. We read the third…
…
continue reading
1
EP10: Is Equality of Opportunity Not Valuable? (On Stephan Kershnar’s Attack on Equality of Opportunity)
1:20:43
1:20:43
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:20:43
This week we have one of our first encounters with the Academic Edgelord final boss, Stephan Kershnar. We enter the Kershnar-sphere by looking at his argument against equality of opportunity. For this edgelord — who is author of papers on adult-child sex, slavery, and more — its actually one of his milder takes. It’s from Why Equality of Opportunit…
…
continue reading
1
EP9: Are There Enough Conservatives in Academia? (On Whittington’s Case for Ideological Diversity)
1:05:15
1:05:15
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:05:15
Academia is often stereotyped as a radical left-wing institution. This is especially true among conservatives who even see universities as “Marxist indoctrination camps.” So much so, that many conservatives are turning their backs on the academy completely. On this episode, we debate whether ideological diversity on campus matters. We consider the …
…
continue reading
1
EP8: Should the Knowledgable Rule? (On Jason Brennan’s “Against Democracy”)
1:21:25
1:21:25
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:21:25
Most political theorists assume that some form of democracy is the only legitimate political regime. Jason Brennan thinks this is an under-examined assumption. In fact, Brennan thinks there are many reasons to be critical of both the existing forms of representative democracy as well as more radical theories that endorse drastically increased democ…
…
continue reading
1
EP7: Should We Support Affirmative Action? (On Pojman’s Case Against Affirmative Action)
1:16:54
1:16:54
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:16:54
In June 2023, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that “Harvard’s and UNC’s admissions programs violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment”. This effectively ended race-based affirmative action in higher education in the United States. This led us to ask, is this outcome a disaster for left-wing politics? On this episo…
…
continue reading
1
EP6: Is A.I. Going To Kill Us All? (On Richard Ngo’s A.I. Safety First Principles)
1:11:21
1:11:21
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:11:21
Many agree there is plenty of reason to worry about existing A.I., including how it perpetuates structural racism, invades privacy, erodes workers’ rights, and entrenches monopolistic firms. But might a future A.I. also take over and dominate, or potentially even destroy humanity, like some Skynet-like scenario? Some technologists worry it might, a…
…
continue reading
1
EP5: Is Whiteness Parasitic? (On Donald Moss’ “On Having Whiteness”)
1:03:42
1:03:42
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:03:42
When psychoanalyst Donald Moss published his essay “On Having Whiteness” in 2021, it caused the right-wing media outrage machine to move into high gear. For example, both the New York Post and the Daily Mail wrote articles that seemed, on our reading, to only react to what was in the abstract. So, we decided we should actually read the entire artic…
…
continue reading
1
EP4: Is it Morally Wrong to Prefer Attractive Partners? (On ‘Lookism’ and William D’Alessandro)
1:13:42
1:13:42
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:13:42
If your partner is attractive, then you might be part of the problem. At least, that’s what one edgelord philosopher is suggesting. We discuss William D’Alessandro’s forthcoming paper, “Is It Bad to Prefer Attractive Partners?” (in the Journal of the American Philosophical Association here). Is this “lookism” a kind of unjustified and harmful discr…
…
continue reading
1
EP3: 5 Years or 5 Lashes? (On Moskos’ & Brennan’s Defense of Flogging)
1:14:11
1:14:11
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:14:11
If you were offered the choice of a brief-but-brutal whipping or an extended stay in prison, which would you take? Probably the former. Is that an argument for flogging? Most people consider the idea of state-sanctioned flogging to be barbaric. Sure, Singapore does it, but they are known for authoritarian laws. Yet, Peter Moskos and Jason Brennan a…
…
continue reading
1
EP2: Did the Unabomber Have a Point? (on Anarcho-Primitivism & Ted Kaczynski)
1:12:30
1:12:30
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:12:30
על ידי Academic Edgelords
…
continue reading
1
EP1: Are We the Academic Edgelords?
1:15:14
1:15:14
נגן מאוחר יותר
נגן מאוחר יותר
רשימות
לייק
אהבתי
1:15:14
על ידי Academic Edgelords
…
continue reading