24. Skylar Neese

Rabbit Hole Happy Hour

On July 5th, 2012, high school sophomore Skylar Neese would sneak out of her bedroom after her parents went to bed for the night. But the next day, Dave and Mary Neese would discover that their daughter never made it back. They looked to her best friends Shelia Eddy and Rachel Shoaf who’d been with her earlier in the night, but who’d claimed to have dropped her off a couple blocks from her apartment around midnight. Police check surveillance videos of the complex and discover Skylar had left again in a mysterious vehicle around 12:30am. Law enforcement concluded that Skylar was a runaway and attempted to get more details from her besties, but they hit wall after wall. The longer Skylar was gone, the more people suspected Skylar's best friends knew more than they were letting on. It wouldn’t take long before one of them would crack and police would discover that the truth was much more horrifying than anticipated.